Duration of status rule vacated: court strikes down DHS fixed-term rule for F-1, J-1 and I visas (Presidents’ Alliance v. DHS)

Duration of Status Rule Vacated: Presidents’ Alliance v. DHS

Disclaimer: We assist with federal U.S. immigration (USCIS) matters only. Attorney Scott A. Maki is licensed in Minnesota only and cannot assist with state-law matters in any other state, including North Dakota.

DHS rule ending duration of status for students (struck down by a court)

On July 17, 2026, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) published a new rule for international students (F visas), exchange visitors (J visas) and foreign media workers (I visas). Today these visitors are allowed to stay for “duration of status” (D/S). That means they may stay as long as they keep doing what they came for, for example studying full time. The new rule would have replaced this with a fixed end date: generally up to four years for students and exchange visitors, and up to 240 days for media workers. Anyone needing more time would have had to ask U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for an extension.

The rule was supposed to start on September 15, 2026. A federal judge in Boston paused it on September 14, 2026. On November 16, 2026, the same judge struck the rule down completely (the court “vacated” it, which means it is cancelled).

Duration of status is still the rule today. The new fixed-term rule is not in effect.

What Presidents’ Alliance v. DHS challenges

On August 18, 2026, a group of colleges, international education groups and unions sued DHS in federal court in Massachusetts. The first group named is the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration. They said the rule was unreasonable and broke federal law. They said DHS did not properly weigh the harm to students and schools, did not consider simpler options, and went beyond its legal power by limiting what students may study.

Duration of status rule: status today

Status as of November 17, 2026 (last change: November 16, 2026): On November 16, 2026, Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV decided the case for the groups that sued, without a trial (this is called “summary judgment”). He cancelled the whole rule. He gave two reasons: the rule was unreasonable (the law calls this “arbitrary and capricious”), and its limits on what students may study go beyond what the immigration law allows. The case in that court is now closed.

The government had already appealed the judge’s September 14 order to a higher court, the First Circuit Court of Appeals. On November 3, 2026, the government asked that court to put the appeal on hold, and the groups that sued agreed. On November 13, 2026, the appeals court said yes and put that appeal on hold for 30 days. At the end of the 30 days, both sides must tell the court where things stand. The government can also appeal the new November 16 decision and ask for it to be paused. As of the morning of November 17, 2026, we have not seen a new appeal or a request to pause the November 16 decision on the public court record.

What this means for you: If you, your spouse or your children are in the U.S. as students (F-1), exchange visitors (J-1) or media workers (I), the old rules still apply. You can stay as long as you keep your status, and your I-94 record should still show “D/S.” For family members filing to extend or change status (Form I-539) or for a work permit (Form I-765), USCIS says it accepts the older form editions and does not accept the new 09/15/26 editions. Use the edition USCIS lists on its website on the day you file. This could change if a higher court pauses the ruling. Call or contact our office if you have questions about your family’s status.

Note: This is a separate case from the court cases on the 75-country immigrant visa pause, the USCIS holds on applications from 39 countries, the USCIS adjustment of status policy and the refugee status termination rule. It does not change the separate travel ban (Presidential Proclamation 10998).

Full details: the duration of status rule and the court ruling

The sections below explain the rule, the court’s reasons and the case timeline in more detail.

What is duration of status (D/S)?

For decades, F, J and I nonimmigrants have been admitted for “duration of status” rather than until a fixed date. An F-1 student keeps status while making normal progress in a full course of study. If a student needs more time, the school’s designated school official (DSO) can extend the program end date. No application to USCIS is needed. Spouses and minor children (F-2, J-2, I dependents) follow the main visa holder’s status.

Duration of status vs. the vacated 2026 fixed-term rule for F-1, J-1 and I visas
Duration of status (still in effect) compared with the 2026 fixed-term rule the court vacated

What would the 2026 duration of status rule have changed?

According to the court’s September 14, 2026 decision, the final rule (91 Fed. Reg. 44976, published July 17, 2026) would have:

  • Admitted F and J nonimmigrants for a fixed period of up to four years, or until the program end date if sooner, and I media representatives for up to 240 days.
  • Required anyone needing more time to file an extension of stay with USCIS, approved only for listed reasons (such as compelling academic or medical reasons) and at USCIS’s discretion, with no appeal from a denial.
  • Barred graduate students from changing programs or transferring schools (with exceptions for extenuating circumstances), and limited transfers by undergraduates in their first year.
  • Allowed students to start a new program only at a higher level than one already completed (for example, no second master’s degree or a business degree after a law degree).
  • Required F and J visa holders who finish their program early to leave within 30 days.

Why did the court vacate the duration of status rule?

In its November 16, 2026 decision, the court adopted its earlier findings that the rule was arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) because DHS (1) did not properly weigh the rule’s costs and benefits, (2) relied on fraud and national security reasons that did not support the change, (3) did not consider less burdensome alternatives, and (4) did not adequately respond to significant public comments. The court added that DHS failed to weigh improvements to its existing student tracking system (SEVIS) as an alternative.

The court also held that the rule’s limits on academic studies are “contrary to statutory authority.” The F-1 law covers any “bona fide student” pursuing a full course of study, and the court found that limits such as banning joint degrees or a second degree at the same level are not reasonably related to the purpose of the student visa. The court rejected DHS’s request to send the rule back to the agency without cancelling it, noting that duration of status has existed for decades and the new rule never took effect.

Presidents’ Alliance v. DHS case timeline

  • August 28, 2025: DHS proposes replacing duration of status with fixed admission periods (90 Fed. Reg. 42070).
  • July 17, 2026: DHS publishes the final rule (91 Fed. Reg. 44976), effective September 15, 2026.
  • August 18, 2026: The Presidents’ Alliance and other plaintiffs file suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts (No. 1:26-cv-13799).
  • September 14, 2026: Judge Saylor grants a preliminary injunction under 5 U.S.C. 705, postponing the rule’s effective date and barring DHS from implementing it (ECF No. 50 memorandum, ECF No. 51 order). USCIS then says it will keep accepting the older editions of Forms I-539 and I-765 and not the 09/15/26 editions.
  • September 30 – October 1, 2026: The government appeals the preliminary injunction to the First Circuit (No. 26-2112).
  • November 3, 2026: The government files an assented-to motion asking the First Circuit to hold the appeal in abeyance (pause it).
  • November 13, 2026: The First Circuit (Judge Lara E. Montecalvo) grants the assented-to motion and holds the appeal in abeyance for thirty days. The briefing schedule is vacated, and the parties must file a status report at the end of the thirty-day period. (This order first appeared on the public appeal docket on November 17.)
  • November 16, 2026: The court grants the plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment, denies the government’s, and vacates the entire final rule under 5 U.S.C. 706 (ECF No. 73). The court enters an order closing the case the same day (ECF No. 74).

Who is affected by the duration of status ruling?

The ruling protects F-1 international students, J-1 exchange visitors (such as researchers, professors and medical residents), I visa foreign media representatives, and their spouses and children in F-2, J-2 and I status. Many of these families later apply for green cards, for example through marriage to a U.S. citizen or a family petition. Keeping status until then matters, because a gap in status can make a later green card application from inside the U.S. harder.

Duration of status rule FAQ

Is the F-1 four-year limit in effect?

No. As of November 16, 2026, the four-year limit never took effect. The court postponed it on September 14, 2026 and vacated the entire rule on November 16, 2026. Students are still admitted for duration of status.

Which Form I-539 and I-765 editions should I use?

USCIS’s Form I-539 page says it accepts the 08/28/24 edition of Form I-539 and the 08/21/25 edition of Form I-765, and does not accept the 09/15/26 editions. Always check the edition date on the USCIS form page on the day you file, because this can change.

Can the government still bring the rule back?

Possibly. The government can appeal the November 16 decision and ask a higher court to pause it. A request alone does not bring the rule back; only a court order would. DHS could also try to write a new rule. We will update this page if that happens.

Questions about a family member’s student or exchange visitor status, or a marriage green card after studying in the U.S.? Contact our office. Maki Law Firm Immigration Services is a family-based immigration law firm located in Fargo, ND. For other recent changes, see our immigration news page.

Read the full case yourself: If you would like to read the court’s full decision yourself, you will find a link here: Memorandum and Order on Cross-Motions for Summary Judgment (November 16, 2026, ECF No. 73). You can also follow every filing on the court docket.

Abbreviations on this page

  • DHS: Department of Homeland Security
  • USCIS: U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (the agency that decides extension and work permit applications)
  • D/S: duration of status
  • F-1 / F-2: student visa / spouse and children of a student
  • J-1 / J-2: exchange visitor visa / spouse and children of an exchange visitor
  • I visa: visa for representatives of foreign media (press, radio, film)
  • I-94: the arrival record showing how long a visitor may stay
  • I-539 / I-765: the form to extend or change status / the work permit form
  • DSO: designated school official (the school employee who manages student records)
  • SEVIS: Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (the government’s database for F and J visa holders)
  • APA: Administrative Procedure Act (the law on how agencies make rules)
  • 5 U.S.C. 705 / 706: sections of federal law letting courts pause (705) or set aside (706) agency rules
  • Fed. Reg.: Federal Register (where federal rules are published)
  • D. Mass.: U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts
  • ECF No.: the number the court gives each filed document

Sources

This update provides general information, not legal advice. This case may change quickly; check back for the latest status.